Skip to content

When Hospital Checklists Don’t Tell The Whole Story

The whole idea behind HHS’ Hospital Compare is simple: patients can shop around by putting in their zip codes and the website churns out a list of nearby hospitals, with detail on available services, care outcomes, patient satisfaction ratings and more.

The aim: to help consumers – and companies that pay for their care – make informed decisions about where to seek medical care; and to pressure hospitals to improve the quality of their services.

But a report that appeared today in the Archives of Surgery says the website isn’t helping Medicare beneficiaries in need of certain high-risk surgery find better facilities.

If hospitals are forced to publicly report the measures they’re taking to prevent surgical infection and blood clots, the thinking goes, they’ll have a stronger incentive to comply with recommended safety measures, and thereby reduce the number of preventable deaths from surgical complications.

That may not be the reality, according to this report. Researchers analyzed the information on the Hospital Compare site from Medicare inpatient stays for 325,052 patients in over 2,000 hospitals who underwent one of six “high-risk” surgeries – such as some open-heart procedures – in 2005 and 2006. Some hospitals only followed certain safety measures in about half the patients, while others did it more than 90 % of the time.

But interestingly, the higher compliance rate didn’t correspond to a lower rate of post-operative deaths most of the time.

The “safer” hospitals did make a difference in one significant way – patients had a lower risk of having an “extended stay” in the hospital.

The lack of association may be due to the fact that the CMS only collects data on “low-leverage” safety measures that aren’t good indicators of surgical quality, the report’s authors say. Their bottom line: CMS needs to find better measures and “devote greater attention to profiling hospitals based on outcomes for improved public reporting and pay-for-performance programs.”

Some of this may come as no surprise: previous studies with the Hospital Compare data have shown wide variations in cost and quality – and found no correlation: if you spend more, it doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll have better care.

This is one of KHN’s “Short Takes” – brief items in the news. For the latest from KHN, check out our

News Section