Court Supports Parents Of Trans Child In Texas ‘Abuse’ Case
Though Texan authorities wanted to investigate the parents under a punitive plan by Gov. Greg Abbott, an appeals court upheld an earlier ruling blocking the investigation. Federal action over Texas' efforts is also expected to play out in the courts. In Idaho, lawmakers are trying an even more restrictive law, punishing parents seeking out-of-state transgender youth treatment.
Dallas Morning News:
Texas Appeals Court Sides With Parent Of Transgender Teen In Case Of Alleged Child Abuse
The lawsuit stems from a nonbinding opinion Paxton issued last month interpreting state law to define certain gender-affirming medical treatments as “child abuse.” Based his opinion, Gov. Greg Abbott then directed child protective services and other agencies to investigate reports of minors receiving these treatments. At least three families with transgender children have been visited by CPS agents since the order went out. On March 1, the state employee and a Houston psychologist sued to block the directive with the backing of the ACLU of Texas and Lambda Legal. Travis County District Court Judge Amy Clark Meachum granted their request to temporarily halt implementation of the directive, which applied just to the plaintiffs, the next day. (McGaughy, 3/9)
CNN:
Texas Files Lawsuit Over Latest Federal Health Guidance That Highlighted Protections For Pediatric Gender Affirming Care
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton announced Wednesday he is suing the Biden administration over guidance from federal health officials that conflicts with his legal opinion that gender affirming procedures in children should be considered "child abuse." Paxton's February legal opinion -- which was seen by many as an attack on transgender children -- prompted Texas Gov. Greg Abbott to direct the state's Department of Family and Protective Services to investigate instances of those procedures. (Rose and Maxouris, 3/9)
Bloomberg Law:
Texas Transgender ‘Abuse’ Policy Portends Biden Investigation
The administration has just two options to stop Texas from investigating families for child abuse if they are suspected of seeking gender-affirming care for transgender children—pulling federal health funding or suing the state. Attorneys say both options are likely being discussed at the Departments of Justice and Health and Human Services, especially in light of strong statements and guidance opposing the state’s actions by President Joe Biden and his agencies March 2. (Stein, 3/10)
In related news from Idaho —
NBC News:
Idaho Lawmakers Seek To Punish Parents Who Take Trans Youth To Other States For Health Care
The Idaho House of Representatives on Tuesday passed legislation to make it a crime punishable by life in prison for a parent to seek out gender-affirming health care for their transgender child. The bill is among 29 pieces of Republican-backed legislation nationwide proposed so far this year to curtail health care for transgender youth, and it coincides with dozens of additional bills seeking to limit what can be discussed about gender identity and sexual orientation in schools and restrict transgender athletes in school sports. (Kingkade, 3/9)
More on Texas' fight against transgender health care —
NBC News:
'Our State Is Terrorizing Us': Texas Families Of Transgender Kids Fight Investigations
L., a mom who lives in Austin, Texas, said she was excited and relieved when her transgender son turned 18 last month, because “he made it.” Her son attempted suicide multiple times, she explained, first when he was just 9 years old. After he came out as trans and started wearing different clothing and using male pronouns, she said she heard him laugh for the first time in a long time. Now, he’s going to college in another state, and L., whose lawyer recommended she go by an initial instead of her full name to protect her family's privacy, thought her family was safe. (Yurcaba, 3/9)
Houston Chronicle:
Dallas-Area Parents Of Transgender Son Say CPS Is Targeting Them Through ‘State Terrorism’
Thousands have remained in the shadows after Gov. Greg Abbott’s directive calling for parents of transgender youth to be investigated for child abuse if they support medical interventions. But one Dallas-area family is speaking out against what they called “state terrorism.” The statement by Amber and Adam Briggle, provided by their lawyer, tells the story of how the couple’s lives have been turned upside down after their family became a target of Texas’ Child Protective Services. The couple and their transgender son have been politically active in recent years, showing up at the Capitol to dissuade lawmakers from passing bills that target children like him. (Goldenstein, 3/8)
The Texas Tribune:
Parents Of Trans Child Who Dined With Paxton Investigated For Child Abuse
In 2016, when Texas tried to stop transgender students from using the bathroom of their choice, there were protests, press conferences and a whole lot of anger directed toward the state’s elected officials. But one mom tried something different — she invited Attorney General Ken Paxton to have dinner at her house with her 8-year-old transgender son. Amber Briggle told The 19th recently that Paxton and her son washed up together in the bathroom before dinner. “He turns around and looks and says, ‘This is nice. It’s been a while since I had kids this age,’” Briggle told The 19th. More than five years later, Paxton has helped set in motion a targeting of families with trans kids unlike anything experts or lawyers say they’ve ever seen — and the Briggles are now caught in the crosshairs. (Klibanoff, 3/8)
The Texas Tribune:
Treatment For Transgender Kids Becomes Litmus Test For Texas Republicans
Gov. Greg Abbott sparked a national uproar last month when he authorized child-abuse investigations into families that allow transgender kids to receive gender-affirming care. But the political momentum toward the move had been building for months, after the failure at the Legislature of a bill to block such treatments for kids paved the way for executive action amid a competitive primary season. Along the way, the issue emerged as a new litmus test for Texas Republicans. The issue is no longer contained to just the party’s fringes — and it is unlikely to go away any time soon as the national fervor grows, Abbott’s directive faces legal challenges and it factors prominently into a slew of GOP primary runoffs. (Svitek, 3/9)
The 19th:
Poll: GOP Voters Are Split On Government Blocking Vital Gender-Affirming Care For Trans Youth
Republicans surveyed by the left-leaning polling firm Data for Progress are nearly evenly split on whether the government should prevent transgender youth from accessing gender-affirming care. The national polling data, shared exclusively with The 19th, suggests that GOP voters are not nearly as supportive of anti-trans bills being pushed by Republican state lawmakers across the country as some Republican politicians may want to believe. The data also carries significance for trans Republicans who spoke with The 19th about running in their local elections. (Rummler, 3/9)
And Disney World weighs in on Florida "Don't Say Gay" law —
NPR:
Disney Now Says It Is Opposed To Florida's 'Don't Say Gay' Bill
The Walt Disney Company has now come out against Florida's Parental Rights In Education bill. The so-called 'Don't Say Gay' bill was passed by Florida's House and Senate and is headed to Gov. Ron DeSantis' desk. The bill would limit discussions of sexual orientation and gender identity in schools. In recent days, Disney employees shared their outrage on social media when the company did not denounce the proposed legislation. On Wednesday, at Disney's annual meeting with shareholders, Disney CEO Bob Chapek acknowledged their anger, saying that he knows "many are upset that we didn't speak out against the bill." (Blair, 3/8)
Politico:
DeSantis Agrees To Meet With Disney CEO Amid 'Don't Say Gay’ Fallout
Walt Disney Co.’s CEO told shareholders on Wednesday that Gov. Ron DeSantis agreed to meet with him to discuss Florida’s “Don’t Say Gay” parental rights bill amid widespread condemnation of the controversial measure. Bob Chapek, the head of the California-based Walt Disney corporation, said he called DeSantis expressing “disappointment and concern” over the legislation and that the Republican governor agreed to meet with him and LGBTQ company leaders over the impact the bill could have, according to a readout of Chapek’s comments provided to POLITICO by Disney. (Atterbury, 3/9)
